Q: Thank you for all you do to educate the public. I’m hoping you guys can settle a debate that’s been going on with a few financial advisors and CPAs regarding the 5-year rule for Roth IRA conversions. I was under the impression that a non-taxable conversion can be withdrawn at any time, even within 5 years of the “backdoor” contribution/conversion, without a 10% penalty.
My personal CPA is adamant that the 10% penalty would apply to a withdrawal of the backdoor conversion amount, but I don’t see why, or where that opinion is supported. Can you please help settle this debate?